It’s been awhile since I’ve posted anything, but I can’t think of a better subject than one of my favorite spirits…Gin.
Gin is very much in revival. Like it’s colorless cousin, Vodka, it was once very much en vogue, serving as base spirit for a myriad of classic cocktails. The Martinez, The Aviation, and The Martini are just some examples.
Due very much to the sensitive and unadventuresome palates of the drinking public, who’d rather slosh down a good ole batch of something mixed in an ice chest, (let’s face it, we’ve all been there),Vodka slammed on the scene. With the advent of good, clean distillation and not without much help from mainstream billboard and creative advertisements, the shelves of liquor stores are filled mostly with vodka.
Now, with the revival of a true blue Cocktail Culture, drinkers are demanding something more..flavor. Subtle flavors. Citrusy, fruity flavors.
Gin, however, has been touting the subtle flavor of a host of botanicals for years…first to hide the harsh taste of bad distillation. These days distillation has become somewhat of an art form, yielding some very interesting product. This ain’t your grandpappy’s white lightning, ya’ll.
Okay, all of this social commentary on drinking vodka and gin does have a point. And the point is a review of New Amsterdam Gin.
I normally do a bit of reading on the product I’m reviewing before I taste, but to be honest with the folks over at New Amsterdam, I did not. I was jonesing for a Martini, and by that I mean a drink made with GIN, DRY VERMOUTH and garnished with a tasty olive or two….or three.
So, I found on the shelf the sample of New Amsterdam Gin I received. I make my Martinis 2 parts gin to 1 part dry vermouth. Shaken or stirred, it’s a toss up and I leave that debate behind like discarded ice.
My first impression was…oh, man…this is Gin in its truest sense. I love Gin, and normally drink Bombay or Beefeater…preferably one with a little bit of juniper bite. While my first taste of New Amsterdam Gin left me with no doubts of that bite, I detected a lot of citrusy flavors in the background. As I made my way through the drink, I found that it really didn’t suit my personal tastes as far as a Gin for making my traditional Martini or Gibson. Instead, I found it more suited for something like a Gin Rickey….a gin drink with juice of a citrus fruit in it. I can see where in a drink like that New Amsterdam Gin would really shine and add depth to those drinks.
I did some reading and looking at the website for New Amsterdam Gin, and found the recipes there were geared toward exactly those sorts of drinks. Mind you, there is nothing wrong with fruit juice in a drink. As a gin drinker, I can and do enjoy other gin-based drinks. While I didn’t have the opportunity for this review to sample them, I am sure that they are delicious. I even think that New Amsterdam would be great as a substitute for vodka in a Bloody Mary perhaps lending a fruity undertone to the spicy nature of that drink. Hell, a good Tom Collins sipped on while around the pool sounds, even in the dead of winter, inviting.
All in all, I appreciate the effort of the distiller’s efforts here in creating a very versatile spirit in New Amsterdam Gin…with, I believe, a true effort to compete with the fruity-flavored vodkas on the market, lending a hand in furthering the gin revival of present. At around $15 for 750ml, New Amsterdam has a definite place behind your bar.

I agree with your observation of the citrus notes in New Amsterdam. The way I exploit it is to pair New Amsterdam-based Martinis or Vespers with sushi. The extra bit of brightness in the gin is a perfect match for typical sushi flavors–the saltiness of soy and nori, the brightness of ginger, and classic fish flavors all combine with the juniper and citrus to make an excellent combination.
You know Doug, that makes sense to me. I’ll definitely have to try that. I’ve been eating lots of sushi lately, so your comment is truly apropos. Thank you!
I haven`t tried this gin but i do know that i would most likely like a gin BM with it..
Trying it for the first time tonight, can’t wait to try it.
I’m not really an olive guy so I prefer my martini’s with a twist, and with that said this gin works very well in a martini for me. Perhaps its the salty brininess of the olives that dont mix well with the citrusy notes of New Amsterdam.
This gin was a big surprise – I haven’t minded it in any of the typical gin cocktails – Martini, Gibson, and Aviation. Even with a bit of fresh squeezed citrus from the back yard, I truly enjoy New Amsterdam.
And I found it for ~$17/1.75 liter bottle, in California.
This gin will be kept in the house until the hot weather is gone. It’s a winner, for sure.
You know, I’m really surprised that this seems to be one of my most popular posts. It seems that New Amsterdam does indeed have a loyal following….and is generating quite a bit of publicity. So, I have to admit, that though it is not my personal favorite…it has earned it’s place in my home bar. So KUDOS! to New Amsterdam Gin!
Drinking a Gin and Tonic with a twist of lime..New Amsterdam makes it a perfect mix..I like it..
I tried NA a couple years ago at Christmas time when it came with a set of nice glasses. I really liked the citrus flavor. For martinis, I found it combined perfectly with Cinzano vermouth. If you haven’t tried that combination I hope you will.
i use new amsterdam for my gimlets because as you suggested it’s perfect with lime juice
I’m a huge fan. Originally bought this while trying to save money on party supplies. I haven’t looked back. I actually prefer this over my old choices, T10 and Kendricks. I drink it straight on the rocks.
Sorry, Hendricks not Kendricks. Damn fat fingers.
This ruined a perfectly good martini. Luckily, it was purchased on sale. I’ll need to try it in some other cocktail.
I just tried New Amsterdam in a Martini, not bad, not great. MUCH much better in a gin+tonic with a twist of lime. i’ll have to try it in a few other drinks, but it’s for sure my go-to for gin and tonics for now on.
Actually, I have to disagree with redingtonb on this one. I’m a big gin drinker, too, and do like juniper-heavy gins. But I stumbled on a bottle of New Amsterdam for$10 in California, and have enjoyed it immensely.
I’m drinking a New Amsterdam martini as I write, and it’s delightful. Yes, heavy on the citrus, but light, drinkable, and ever-so-slightly sweet. Serve it with a twist instead of an olive, and know what to expect, and I’m willing to bet that you’ll find this a pleasant drink. (Interestingly, I DON’T like this gin in a G&T. Somehow always turns bitter when I make them.)
You may want to try different tonic water brands with your G&Ts. I personally haven’t had enough experience with tonic to pick out a favorite but many are on the market. Check http://www.kegworks.com and you’ll see a few. Also there are recipes to make your own.
i agree with redingtonb.
i was not impressed with this gin.
The citrus element is fine, but there is a weird vanilla sweetness to it that seems out of keeping with just about any traditional gin drink.
It goes from bothersome in a Tom Collins to catastrophic in a Dirty Martini.
Not quite what I had expected. This Gin doesn’t quite do it for a Gin & Tonic or a London Sapphire Club, but I will try your suggestions on a citrus drink.
Mixing a pitcher of Southside cocktails, with lime, so this is a winner of a Gin at 1/2 price of the more established name brands.
I have to say that I really don’t like this gin. The only way I have found it to be acceptable to drink is in a super dry (little to no vermouth–not the way I normally prefer) martini. Any other use has proven disappointing at best, ghastly at worst. to me, this tastes like vodka mixed with artificial ”gin” flavoring and some artificial orange and lemon flavors, with a little sugar or nutra sweet thrown in. I’m sorry, but life’s too short to drink this stuff.
Also, I this it’s the only spirit I have ever had that caused me to black out. I’ve read others commenting on this on the web. Despite it’s low proof, I feel inebriated after 2-3 drinks, so if you’re looking to get totally s**tfaced and forget everything, I guess this is a quick and cheap way to do so.
For those who prefer real gin to vodka mixed with lemon dishwasher detergent, steer clear
Thanks, undertaking. I’m a gut-reaction Schwepps man, myself. Maybe I should upgrade.
I also should say that I know what curseofleisure means about drinking this gin “very dry.” But I actually take this as a point in its favor; a martini made with this stuff and just a hint of dry vermouth is great, especially in hot weather and on a budget.
I really enjoyed it with lime club soda and a twist of lime AWESOME! and by the way all gins start life as a neutral (VODKA)
I was looking for a cheap Gin that was drinkable. I love gin and my favorites are Sapphire for it harsher juniper flavor and Hendricks for it smoothness. As I type this I am sipping a Martini with New Amsterdam Gin. I like the citrus note to it and find it very refreshing. It is smooth and easy on the pallet. I even think it is fine with an olive garnish. It definitely not Sapphire or Hendricks but I would not turn down any drink made with the New Amsterdam. I think it would make a heck or a Bramble and is at home as a martini or in a gin and tonic. It has definitely earned a spot in the liqueur cabinet. Not the perfect Gin but for the money not bad.
Thanks for the comment. I have to admit that New Amsterdam has grown on me a bit. That post is the most popular on the blog.
I have to say I was hooked on sapphire for years, but tried on a recommendation. I didn’t really like it that much in my first martini. I like them pretty dry and dirty. It was really citrus heavy. But much to my surprise the second time I made one I really liked it. I been making it a regular for my Martina’s for the past year and a half at least.
At a recent party, I was served a wonderful coctail- A Sparkletini– using this Gin and it was fabulous. I loved it! I now use it in my G&T with a little Roses Lime. Wonderful!
I just had New Amsterdam gin in a gin cocktail made with gin, St. Germain, and tonic; was looking for more information on New Amsterdam gin (silly me, thought it was a craft NY state gin; guess I have to look elsewhere in NY for that). Interesting concoction for a person whose idea of heaven in a G&T is Bombay Sapphire … a little sweet for my taste, but that may have been the contribution of the elder flower.
Just went to the local discount lickie to do a homework project. Items imported from other countries. Teacher suggested WalMart, Walgreens, Dollar Store where everything is from China. While checking “what” came from “where” I noticed in the gin aisle between my favorite Gilbey’s and “I’ll have to take out a small personal loan” Bombay Sapphire was a beautiful bottle of New Amsterdam for $19. After checking to make sure it wasn’t a wrong price, I bought it and am enjoying a very fruity G&T. Guess it pays to shop instead of just buying the usual.